This ecommerce brand grew new customer revenue 521% YoY when they stopped taking Meta reporting at face value and built out true acquisition funnels.

Posted on
On paper, everything looked strong. Meta was reporting efficient ROAS. Revenue in-platform was growing. Spend was scaling. But topline business growth wasn’t keeping pace. Something didn’t add up.

When we dug deeper, the issue became clear:

  • A significant portion of Meta spend was converting existing customers—people who would have purchased anyway, often through email or direct. So while Meta looked like it was driving performance, it wasn’t creating much net-new demand.
  • They were double paying for the same customers once to acquire them, and again to convert them. And Meta’s reporting didn’t make that distinction obvious.

So we rebuilt the system around what actually matters:  Incremental Growth

  • Separated new vs. existing customer journeys
  • Tightened targeting and exclusions
  • Reworked creative to speak to net-new audiences
  • Optimized toward acquisition—not just reported conversions

THE RESULTS:

  • CPCs dropped 53%.
  • New customer revenue increased 521% YoY.
  • And for the first time—Meta’s performance translated to real topline growth, not just in-platform results.
Same product. Same budget. But now, every dollar was driving new demand. Less recycled revenue. More actual growth.
Back to blog